HIGHER odds of stillbirth among Asian and Black mothers persisted after adjustment for maternal characteristics and ultrasound use in a large UK analysis, suggesting that these measured factors do not fully explain ethnic disparities.
Researchers also found no statistically significant ethnic differences within the subgroup whose babies were suspected to be small for gestational age (SGA) before birth. However, limited statistical precision means this finding cannot establish that enhanced surveillance eliminates inequalities.
Examining UK Maternity Data
The secondary cohort analysis used data from the DESiGN trial, conducted across 13 UK maternity units. Researchers included 179,036 singleton pregnancies resulting in birth between November 2016 and February 2019, from 24 weeks’ gestation and before 43 weeks, without antenatally diagnosed major congenital anomalies.
Maternal ethnicity was self-reported and grouped as Asian, Black, multiethnic, White or other ethnicities. The primary outcome was stillbirth from 24 weeks’ gestation.
Investigators assessed whether adjustment for maternal and pregnancy characteristics, including age, deprivation, body mass index, smoking and medical conditions, changed the association between ethnicity and stillbirth. They then additionally adjusted for ultrasound scans performed after 24 weeks.
Differences Remain After Adjustment
Compared with White mothers, adjusted odds of stillbirth were higher among Asian mothers (odds ratio: 1.6; 95% confidence interval: 1.3–2.0) and Black mothers (1.8; 1.4–2.3) after accounting for maternal characteristics.
Further adjustment for ultrasound use produced similar findings: odds ratios were 1.5 for Asian mothers and 1.9 for Black mothers. These results indicate that the recorded maternal factors and scan use did not account for the observed disparities.
In subgroup analyses, differences persisted when SGA was not suspected antenatally. When clinicians suspected SGA, defined as estimated fetal weight below the tenth percentile, the researchers did not detect a difference in stillbirth odds by ethnicity.
Antenatal suspicion of SGA was treated as a marker of entry into enhanced surveillance pathways, rather than proof of fetal growth restriction or a direct measure of every aspect of subsequent care.
Understanding Surveillance and Inequality
The subgroup findings raise questions about whether recognition of fetal compromise and subsequent management could contribute to more equitable outcomes. However, the formal interaction test was not statistically significant, and stillbirth was uncommon within the suspected-SGA subgroup.
An absence of statistically significant differences therefore does not demonstrate equivalent risk. Nor can this observational analysis establish that surveillance caused the pattern observed.
The authors call for research into cultural, psychosocial and systemic influences on maternity care. Factors such as language barriers, care engagement and experiences of racism were not directly assessed.
Improving detection and management of pregnancies at risk remains an important research priority, alongside understanding the broader barriers that may contribute to persistent stillbirth inequalities.
Reference
Winsloe C et al. Ethnic disparities in stillbirth and the effect of maternal factors, antenatal ultrasound, and antenatally suspected small-for-gestational-age as a marker of enhanced antenatal surveillance in the UK (DESiGN): a secondary cohort analysis nested within a randomised trial. Lancet Obstet Gynaecol Womens Health. 2026. doi:10.1016/S3050-5038(26)00288-8.
Featured image: makistock on AdobeStock