What’s Holding Back Antimicrobial Stewardship?

This site is intended for healthcare professionals

What’s Holding Back Antimicrobial Stewardship?

Author:

Key Summary:

  • Economic and structural barriers hinder antimicrobial stewardship.
  • Education gaps contribute to inappropriate antimicrobial use.
  • Shared One Health definitions could improve stewardship.

Economic pressures, conflicting expectations, and gaps in education are undermining efforts to promote appropriate antimicrobial use across human and animal health, according to new qualitative research highlighting the complexities of antimicrobial stewardship.

The findings, particularly relevant during World Antimicrobial Resistance Awareness Week 2026, suggest that successful stewardship initiatives must address the practical challenges faced by healthcare professionals, livestock producers, consumers, and policymakers rather than focusing solely on prescribing behaviour.

Antimicrobial stewardship programmes aim to optimise antimicrobial use, maximising therapeutic benefits while minimising risks, including the development of antimicrobial resistance (AMR). However, researchers highlighted the absence of a universally agreed definition of appropriate antimicrobial use, which complicates efforts to evaluate prescribing quality and implement consistent stewardship strategies across different settings.

Economic and Structural Pressures Shape Antimicrobial Use

The qualitative study involved four focus groups conducted in 2024, bringing together livestock producers, consumers, healthcare professionals, and policymakers. Researchers used thematic analysis informed by grounded theory to explore how stakeholders understood appropriate antimicrobial use and the factors influencing stewardship decisions.

Two overarching themes emerged: structural and economic barriers, and access to information and education.

Within animal health, participants highlighted tensions between consumer preferences and the realities of livestock management. Growing demand for free-range and antibiotic-free produce was identified as a potential source of conflict with the practical need to administer antimicrobials when animals become ill.

Differences between large and small livestock enterprises also influenced antimicrobial use, alongside regulatory restrictions governing off-label treatment. These findings suggest that stewardship approaches must account for the economic and operational circumstances of livestock producers while maintaining appropriate animal welfare standards.

Similar challenges were identified in human healthcare, where time constraints, limited opportunities for follow-up appointments, and differing expectations between patients and prescribers influenced decisions about antimicrobial treatment.

These pressures may complicate efforts to ensure that antimicrobials are prescribed only when clinically appropriate, particularly when healthcare professionals must balance patient expectations with clinical judgement and service limitations.

Education and Communication Gaps Undermine Stewardship

The second major theme concerned the availability, accessibility, and effectiveness of antimicrobial stewardship information.

Participants identified gaps in education for livestock producers, alongside limited public understanding of what constitutes appropriate antimicrobial use. These knowledge gaps may contribute to misconceptions about antimicrobial treatment and create additional challenges for professionals responsible for prescribing or administering these medicines.

The findings also highlighted opportunities to improve communication through existing but underused channels, enabling more consistent messaging tailored to specific audiences and settings.

Researchers suggested that effective antimicrobial stewardship education must recognise the different needs and experiences of stakeholders across human and animal health, rather than relying on a single approach.

Developing a Shared One Health Definition

A central finding was the need to establish a shared understanding of appropriate antimicrobial use across sectors.

The One Health approach recognises the interconnected nature of human, animal, and environmental health, making cross-sector collaboration important in tackling AMR.

However, the study demonstrated that antimicrobial decisions are shaped by different clinical, economic, regulatory, and social considerations depending on the setting. Consequently, developing a universally applicable definition of appropriate use may require flexibility to accommodate these differences.

Researchers emphasised that establishing contextualised, consensus-based definitions would provide a foundation for measuring prescribing quality, benchmarking practice, and identifying where stewardship interventions are most needed.

The findings will inform a forthcoming international Delphi process, which will seek expert consensus on practical and implementable One Health definitions of appropriate antimicrobial use.

As global efforts to combat AMR continue, the study highlights that improving antimicrobial stewardship requires more than raising awareness of resistance. Addressing structural barriers, strengthening education, and establishing shared standards across sectors may be equally important in supporting responsible antimicrobial use and preserving treatment effectiveness.

Reference

Allegra Schermuly, Ri Scarborough, Leslie Dowson, Leanne Teoh, Ruby Biezen, Kirsten Bailey, Brian Hur, Brendan McMullan, Courtney Ierano, Laura Hardefeldt, Contextualizing a One Health definition of appropriate antimicrobial use, JAC-Antimicrobial Resistance, Volume 8, Issue 6, December 2026, dlag240, https://doi.org/10.1093/jacamr/dlag240

Adobe Stock

Each article is made available under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-Non Commercial 4.0 License.

Rate this content's potential impact on patient outcomes

Average rating 0 / 5. Vote count: 0

No votes so far! Be the first to rate this content.